
One of my future goals is to write a graphic novel. I have been wanting to start reading comic books for a while. I recently found a comic book store in town so I went there last Friday and purchased four comics. They are:
GI Joe Issue 4 (IDW)
The Amazing Spiderman Issue 590 (Marvel)
Terminator Salvation Issue 3 (IDW)
Captain America Comics 70th Anniversary Issue 1 (Marvel)
After reading, I decided to review each comic based on four categories: cover, story, artwork, and quality. Since I have very little knowledge of comics, I will simply judge them against each other and give my opinion.
Cover
This was a difficult decision for me. The cover of Spiderman has a well drawn, colorful design. Terminator has a more realistic, intimidating design that fits well with the movie. In the end, Spiderman gets the win with Terminator a close second. The Captain America cover is less exciting, which gives it the third spot. Lastly, the GI Joe cover is boring and by far my least favorite.
1. The Amazing Spiderman
2. Terminator Salvation
3. Captain America
4. GI Joe
Story
I will not get into the specifics of each comic's story. I will say GI Joe and Captain America comic both had weak stories. Captain america takes last place because half the pages consist of a chase. Not much story to be found.
1. Terminator Salvation
2. The Amazing Spiderman
3. GI Joe
4. Captain America.
Artwork
Spiderman easily wins for best artwork. The pages are full of color, characters, and have great backgrounds. While the characters aren’t as well drawn, Terminator’s artwork creates the perfect atmosphere for the story. The artwork in GI Joe was the worst of the group.
1. The Amazing Spiderman
2. Terminator Salvation
3. Captain America
4. GI Joe
Quality/Bonus Features
The IDW comics have a harder cover and thicker pages than the marvel comics. Marvel makes up for this by charging $1 less for The Amazing Spiderman. Captain America features a classic CA comic in the second half of the book, but it does little to make up for the poor story quality of the new issue.
1. TIE: GI Joe/Terminator Salvation
2. The Amazing Spiderman
3. Captain America
Overall Winner
It was a close race between Spiderman and Terminator. Spiderman has the best cover and artwork, but came second to Terminator in Story. Terminator has better quality, but Spiderman costs $1 less. Based on these conclusions, The Amazing Spiderman is the winner because it is a more complete package and is a superior comic to Terminator Salvation (although it was a close battle). I would buy both again.
Click Here to see all the covers and samples from the comics!